Results of recent studies using BAPTA/AM have raised a serious question on whether Ca(2+) signal is truly involved in regulating the progression of apoptosis. To resolve this question, we examined the differential effects of three different Ca(2+) signaling blockers (BAPTA/AM, membrane-impermeant BAPTA, and heparin) on UV-induced apoptosis in HeLa cells. We found that although the membrane-permeable form of BAPTA (i.e., BAPTA/AM) could not inhibit cell death, the membrane-impermeant form of BAPTA, loaded into the cytosol by electroporation, clearly protected cells from entering apoptosis. Furthermore, when we injected heparin to block Ca(2+) release from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to cytosol, apoptosis was greatly suppressed. These findings strongly suggest that elevation of cytosolic Ca(2+) is part of the signal that drives the progression of apoptosis. The negative result of BAPTA/AM is probably due to its dual effect on subcellular Ca(2+) distribution; besides suppressing the Ca(2+) elevation in cytosol, BAPTA/AM can also enter into the ER to reduce the free Ca(2+) level there. The depletion of Ca(2+) in ER is believed to stimulate apoptosis and thus would counterbalance the protection effect of BAPTA/AM in suppressing the cytosolic Ca(2+) elevation.
Copyright 2001 Academic Press.