Integrating Validity Evidence to Revise a Child Abuse Knowledge Test for Early Childhood Education Providers: A Mixed Methods Approach

Am J Eval. 2022 Dec;43(4):559-583. doi: 10.1177/10982140211002901. Epub 2021 Nov 22.

Abstract

Knowledge tests used to evaluate child protection training program effectiveness for early childhood education providers may suffer from threats to construct validity given the contextual variability inherent within state-specific regulations around mandated reporting requirements. Unfortunately, guidance on instrument revision that accounts for such state-specific mandated reporting requirements is lacking across research on evaluation practices. This study, therefore, explored how collection and integration of validity evidence using a mixed methods framework can guide the instrument revision process to arrive at a more valid program outcome measure.

Keywords: child abuse knowledge test; child maltreatment; effectiveness outcomes; instrument revision; mandated reporting; mixed methods; validity.