Role of Quantitation of Saline Bubble Studies in Patients with Liver Cirrhosis

Abstract

Objective: Microbubble contrast echocardiography with a late positive signal enables the detection of intrapulmonary vascular dilation, including hepatopulmonary syndrome, in patients with end-stage liver disease. We assessed the relationship between the severity of bubble study and clinical outcome.

Methods: We retrospectively analyzed 163 consecutive patients with liver cirrhosis who underwent an echocardiogram with bubble study from 2018 to 2021. Patients who were diagnosed with a late positive signal were divided into three groups: grade 1 (1-9 bubbles), grade 2 (10-30 bubbles) and grade 3 (>30 bubbles).

Results: Fifty-six percent of the patients had a late positive bubble study (grade 1: 31%, grade 2: 23%, grade 3: 46%). Patients with grade 3 had a significantly higher international normalized ratio, model for end-stage liver disease score and Child-Pugh score and a lower peripheral oxygen saturation compared with patients with a negative study. In patients undergoing liver transplant (LT), survival rates were similar among the groups (3-mo: >87%, 1-y: >87%, 2-y: >83%). However, survival rate was lower in grade 3 patients without LT (3-mo: 81%, 1-y: 64%, 2-y: 39%).

Conclusion: Patients with grade 3 had much worse mortality without LT compared with other groups. However, after LT, all grades had equal survival. Therefore, patients with grade 3 may be considered as higher priority for LT.

Keywords: Child–Pugh score; End-stage liver disease; Hepatopulmonary syndrome; Intrapulmonary vascular dilation; Late positive bubble study; Liver transplant; Model for end-stage liver disease score; Outcome; Saline bubble study; Transthoracic echocardiogram.