MRI in patients with a cerebral aneurysm clip; review of the literature and incident databases and recommendations for the Netherlands

Abstract

Background: In the past ferromagnetic cerebral aneurysm clips that are contraindicated for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) have been implanted. However, the specific clip model is often unknown for older clips, which poses a problem for individual patient management in clinical care.

Methods: Literature and incident databases were searched, and a survey was performed in the Netherlands that identified time periods at which ferromagnetic and non-ferromagnetic clip models were implanted. Considering this information in combination with a national expert opinion, we describe an approach for risk assessment prior to MRI examinations in patients with aneurysm clips. The manuscript is limited to MRI at 1.5 T or 3 T whole body MRI systems with a horizontal closed bore superconducting magnet, covering the majority of clinical Magnetic Resonance (MR) systems.

Results: From the literature a list of ferromagnetic clip models was obtained. The risk of movement or rotation of the clip due to the main magnetic field in case of a ferromagnetic clip is the main concern. In the incident databases records of four serious incidents due to aneurysm clips in MRI were found. The survey in the Netherlands showed that from 2000 onwards, no ferromagnetic clips were implanted in Dutch hospitals.

Discussion: Recommendations are provided to help the MR safety expert assessing the risks when a patient with a cerebral aneurysm clip is referred for MRI, both for known and unknown clip models. This work was part of the development of a guideline by the Dutch Association of Medical Specialists.

Keywords: Aneurysm; Clips; Guideline; Magnetic Resonance Imaging; Safety.