Development of an image quality evaluation system for bedside chest X-ray images using scatter correction processing

Abstract

In plain radiography, scattered X-ray correction processing (Virtual Grid: VG) is used to estimate and correct scattered rays in images. We developed an objective evaluation system for bedside chest X-ray images using VG and investigated its usefulness. First, we trained the blind/referenceless image spatial quality evaluator (BRISQUE) on 200 images obtained by portable chest radiography. We then evaluated optimal chest phantom VG images as well as those that deviated from the VG setting conditions using BRISQUE. Furthermore, we conducted a subjective evaluation using the mean opinion score (MOS) and established an objective evaluation system for VG images. Finally, the degree of agreement between the MOS subjectively evaluated by 14 radiological technologists and that determined by the objective evaluation system for 100 clinical images obtained by portable chest radiography was calculated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. The correlation coefficient between the BRISQUE score and MOS for chest phantom images was - 0.96 (p < 0.05). The two scores showed a very high linear correlation, indicating the potential of the BRISQUE score as an alternative to MOS. The Cohen's kappa coefficient for the objective evaluation system using the optimal conversion table was 0.42. Conversely, there was a very high detection rate of 82.86% for poor-quality images. An objective evaluation system for bedside chest X-ray images using VG that uses no-reference image quality evaluation helps provide proper image quality. Furthermore, such a system can be constructed with a small amount of training data, which increases the possibility of introducing it to a variety of facilities.

Keywords: Chest X-ray image; No-reference image quality assessment; Portable radiography; Scattered X-ray correction processing; Subjective evaluation.